|
|
Introduction for the Doctor with Practical Suggestions
1. In German - speaking medicine autogenous training (AT) is, at present,
the best understood and most widely used method of
psychotherapy. The scientific researcher J. H. SCHULZ,
who developed this ingenious system of con centrative
self-relaxation, devoted decades of work to the testing
of its broad spectrum of indications as relaxation
therapy. It comprises all "nervous" or
neuro-vegetative, therefore functional or conversion
neurotic clinical pictures, psychosomatic diseases such
as Asthma bronchiale, Colitis ulcerosa, essential
hypertonia, etc. But, after thorough practice in this
pragmatic method, the patient can also learn to control,
more or less himself, psychoneurotic symptoms, such as
states of anxiety, slight depressive neuroses and
character maladjustments. Principally, therefore, those
30-40% of all patients who suffer from diseases with
psychological or partially psychological causes can be
treated by AT. But, as is well-known, this method can
also help healthy people, by means of the "prophylactic
pause", to reduce and prevent stress to which
ever-increasing numbers of the population are exposed
nowadays.
1.1 The AT therapy requires that the doctor himself masters the method
and personally instructs his patient in it. The patient
must meet certain requirements of intelligence, emphaty
and strength of character with regard to the regular
exercise he has to perform himself.
1.2 The effect of AT depends, to a certain extent, on the feedback to the
cerebral cortex of the state of muscular tension (sense
of heaviness), of the vascular circulation (experience
of warmth), of the respiratory process (respiratory
control), and the blood circulation in the epigastrium
("solar plexus"); this is achieved by a
gradually increasing awareness of the above-named
vegetative body functions. It is only after months of
continuous practice that the patient achieves the
decisive control of these functions ("Practising
method").
2. During the last decade there has been a tendency in scientific
research in the USA to use electronic instruments for
such "Bio-Feedback" processes. The aim of
these experiments, as far as they are concerned with
therapeutic application in human beings, has been to
create a state of modified consciousness and of
relaxation, similar to that achieved by AT. Out of the
various possibilities, however, only two bio-feedback
systems have emerged which, on the strength of broad
basic research, may claim to be of clinical interest.
These are the feedback of muscular actions by means of
the Electromyelograph (EMG-feedback) for the treatment
of migraine and tension headache, and the control of the
heart action in cases of cardiac disorders. The latter
procedure is still on trial.
Top
3. In Germany a group of researchers worked along different lines. They
examined the feedback of the respiratory movement,
referred to as "Respiration Feedback" (Rfb)
under its scientific designation, or as "Breathing
Feedback" in its practice-related name. Professor
Hanscarl Leuner, neurologist and psychotherapist, Head
of the Department of Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics of
the teaching hospital of Göttingen University, who is
well-known for his many years of research in the field
of modified states of consciousness, observed that
physical-psychological relaxation (Hypnoid) and
respiratory type correlate in a certain way (e.g. in AT,
sleep, coma, during Yoga and meditation exercises).
Since 1970 he and his study group have been developing
and testing an electronic apparatus which scans the
respiratory movement by means of a sensor on the patient
and converts it without delay by amplification into an
optical and/or acoustic signal, that is, translates it
into a light of increasing and decreasing intensity and/or
a tone (headphone) of changing pitch. The patient is
thus distinctly aware of his breathing rhythm and his
respiratory rate, without requiring any prior training.
Prof. Leuner's expectations were not only confirmed, but
in part even exceeded during the physiological and
clinical trials. The EEG distinctly shows a considerable
reduction in cerebral activity and thus the state of
wake-fulness. It exceeds the EEG-changes during hypnosis,
AT (and Alpha-Feedback) in the sense of a marked
reduction of violance. At the same time the muscular
tone (sense of heaviness in AT and in EMG-feedback) is
distinctly reduced. There is a strong subjective
awareness of the psychological influence of the
procedure, which runs parallel to this physical "conversion"
("Umschaltung", J. H. SCHULZ ). It was
possible to establish this statistically with
significant frequency by means of the semantic
differential ("Polaritätenprofil", HOFSTÄTTER
) in the following adjectives of subjective experience:
"relaxed, at ease, indifferent, composed,
comfortable, sure, safe, free, light, serene".
3.1 The clinical trial of Rfb was carried out on a random group of 200
outpatients. They came from a medical and a psychiatric
policlinic of a teaching hospital as well as from a
neurological practice (ages 18-50 years, average age 33
1/2 years, average duration of symptoms 4 years).
Patients with psychoses and internal diseases were
excluded. The complete course of treatment consisted of
15 half-hour sessions and was to be supported by a
further 8 sessions. After about 5 sessions at the latest
the above-mentioned state of deep relaxation was
achieved. Just under 90% of the patients felt that the
treatment was agreeable, about 50% were willing to
continue with it, in over 70% an objectively adequate to
very good improvement of their symptoms could be
observed. A comprehensive paper is available on request.
Top
3.2. What are the Advantages of Respiratory Feedback?
a) The time required for the instruction in relaxation is cut down
considerably; the tangible therapeutic effect manifests
itself within 3-4 weeks.
b) The training aim is achieved with a high degree of certainty.
c) The state of relaxation is intensive, and thus especially efficacious.
d) Rfb makes no demands on empathy, intelligence or will-power on the
part of the patient, except for the ability to yield to
the state of relaxation.
e) The method is therefore suitable for patients of all social groups.
f) The doctor need not himself have learned the procedure. The training
of the patient can largely be left to trained auxiliary
personnel (training courses on request).
3.3. Practical Suggestions
3.3.1 Indications: Generally speaking: almost all conditions for which
neuro-vegetative or the well-known minor tranquillizers
are prescribed, or where AT is indicated;
vegetative-functional disorders of all kinds (after an
organic background has been eliminated), so-called
conversion neuroses or psychosomatic states, but also
psycho-neurotic symptoms, such as states of anxiety,
phobias, slight depressive neuroses, as well as the
group of acute or chronic stress-related reactions.
Stress prophylaxis in stress susceptible asthenic
persons or persons exposed to great stress.
A statistical survey of the groups of diseases, the change of the test
profiles and some individual reports by patients are
available. Only about 5% of an unselected group of
patients proved totally unsuitable for the treatment.
3.3.2 Contra Indications: Severe psychiatric symptoms, such as psychoses
or suspected psychoses, or borderline cases, an
abnormally restricted level of intelligence, imaginary
of the patient with regard to the method or its
rejections for any other reasons (clarifying discussion
before commencing treatment).
3.3.3 External Conditions: A quiet, darkened exercise room, positioning
of the apparatus, comfortable couch (with
BIOSWING-System are the best), auxiliary personnel
trained in the procedure (with first-hand experience,
i.e. introduction by means of a course organized by MFB.
3.3.4 Time Schedule: One exercise takes 30-40 minutes. Double sessions
are also possible. Including contact conversation,
fitting of the sensor and brief concluding discussion,
50 minutes have to be allowed per session. A course of
treatment consists of 15 sessions. 3-4 sessions per week
should be carried out, depending on the severity of the
symptoms. If the patient refuses to continue with the
treatment after 5 sessions (as is extremely rarely the
case), or if he believes that he does not benefit from
the treatment, Rfb is not indicated.
3.3.5 After-treatment: 8 sessions, once weekly, are recommended in order
to maintain the effect. Occasionally patients avoid the
after-treatment if they are feeling well. In the
concluding discussion an offer of after-treatment should
be made which the patient may take up if he should
experience renewed difficulties at a later date. After
the course of treatment is completed the doctor should
conduct a brief concluding orientation discussion, in
order to form an impression of the effect of Rfb and to
determine further therapy accordingly.
3.3.6 Medication: During the treatment with Rfb an attempt should be made
to discontinue any neuro-vegetative and/or sedative
medication. In cases where medication is indispensable,
the dosage should be reduced to a minimum and then kept
at a constant level (Instruction of the patient).
3.3.7 Interference Factors: In the treatment with Rfb these may arise
from circumstances connected with the patient's own
psyche, such as imaginary fears.
1 Leuner, H.:
Das Respiratorische Feedback (Rfb), intensive
Entspannungstherapie und ihre klinischen Ergebnisse bei
Neurosen und psychovegetativen Störungen.
Top
Biofeedback
|
|
|